He’s dead, jim.
Pages: 12
Did a particular event happen or are you just referring to recent forum activity (or the lack thereof).
I very much enjoyed this forum, too, back when I could actually help people.
I very much enjoyed this forum, too, back when I could actually help people.
Last edited on
Yes, the forum is dead — or a lumbering zombie at best.
It isn’t just cplusplus.com. The C++ forum at SO doesn’t seem to get as much traffic as it did just a year ago (in my subjective observation), and a lot of other C and C++ -flavored forums that used to litter the internet have dried up.
I think it’s pretty amazing that Twicker hasn’t taken it down yet. I’d imagine he’s paying more for the forum now than the ad revenue brings him.
It isn’t just cplusplus.com. The C++ forum at SO doesn’t seem to get as much traffic as it did just a year ago (in my subjective observation), and a lot of other C and C++ -flavored forums that used to litter the internet have dried up.
I think it’s pretty amazing that Twicker hasn’t taken it down yet. I’d imagine he’s paying more for the forum now than the ad revenue brings him.
Last edited on
I'd imagine there'd be much more traffic if the site's login stuff wasn't broken.
Coding/programming jobs aren't hiring very well right now, so I imagine there's been less people going into the field perhaps.
Though, the biggest reason traffic has slowed, has to be AI.
I can't imagine having started my account all those years ago to ask questions if I had these powerful AIs back then. Would never have needed to ask anything in this forum.
The AI also doesn't get mad when someone just wants the answers to their homework..
I remember having this engineering/physics question I asked in the popular overflow/exchange forum. I got some mixed answers and didn't know how to even apply one of the formulas.
I had a math problem I asked in the math exchange whatever forum - but no one could actually give me a solved formula.
I eventually solved both things myself. In testing, a couple of these powerful AIs (GPT5 thinking is insanely intelligent) could now solve both problems in minutes - even though it took me much much longer..
Forums are a place where humans gather to share their knowledge. However, AI is the ultimate database of human knowledge - given as if from a professional at your disposal.
Sadly, these forums just can't compete.
Coding/programming jobs aren't hiring very well right now, so I imagine there's been less people going into the field perhaps.
Though, the biggest reason traffic has slowed, has to be AI.
I can't imagine having started my account all those years ago to ask questions if I had these powerful AIs back then. Would never have needed to ask anything in this forum.
The AI also doesn't get mad when someone just wants the answers to their homework..
I remember having this engineering/physics question I asked in the popular overflow/exchange forum. I got some mixed answers and didn't know how to even apply one of the formulas.
I had a math problem I asked in the math exchange whatever forum - but no one could actually give me a solved formula.
I eventually solved both things myself. In testing, a couple of these powerful AIs (GPT5 thinking is insanely intelligent) could now solve both problems in minutes - even though it took me much much longer..
Forums are a place where humans gather to share their knowledge. However, AI is the ultimate database of human knowledge - given as if from a professional at your disposal.
Sadly, these forums just can't compete.
Last edited on
| zapshe wrote: |
|---|
| I'd imagine there'd be much more traffic if the site's login stuff wasn't broken. |
I had forgot this was even a problem. Got so used to holding Ctrl while pressing Log in.
https://cplusplus.com/forum/lounge/284671/#msg1233786
| As a temporary workaround you can hold down Ctrl while pressing the "log in" button. That'll give access to the login form. The "0" page will open in another tab which you can just close or ignore. |
| zapshe wrote: |
|---|
| Though, the biggest reason traffic has slowed, has to be AI. |
It has been low for a long time, way before the AI craze started. Competition sure has had a big effect on forums like these but I think the biggest problem has been that new people can't sign up. Beginners have always been the driving force on website like this but the last few years we have just been discussing among us oldies that already have accounts.
https://cplusplus.com/forum/lounge/285445/#msg1239875
| Suspicion confirmed, I tested creating a new account, using both the Beta and Legacy sites. Over 30 minutes later still no confirmation email at either of the email addys. |
Last edited on
Yes, people can't sign up sadly. Definitely the #1 reason this particular site has lowered traffic.
Though forums in general likely have a huge reduction in traffic due to AI. I've been on many forums over the years, and I can't imagine going to one anymore with questions..
Though forums in general likely have a huge reduction in traffic due to AI. I've been on many forums over the years, and I can't imagine going to one anymore with questions..
| Though, the biggest reason traffic has slowed, has to be AI. |
Edit: Sorry, you already said that. It's just frustrating so I wanted to repeat it.
"He's dead, jim."
Last edited on
Yea, I agree that THIS site's main issue is registration being broken.
Though, I can't imagine what I'd need to ask in a C++ forum that I couldn't Google or ask an AI about faster. Forums will end up being more about community rather than actual problem solving.
Of course, incredibly complex topics that an AI may struggle with would still appear in forums. As well as forums that deal with physical engineering could better benefit from real hands-on experience over an AI for some problems.
May Jim rest in peace.
EDIT:
Let's have a party at my place.
Though, I can't imagine what I'd need to ask in a C++ forum that I couldn't Google or ask an AI about faster. Forums will end up being more about community rather than actual problem solving.
Of course, incredibly complex topics that an AI may struggle with would still appear in forums. As well as forums that deal with physical engineering could better benefit from real hands-on experience over an AI for some problems.
May Jim rest in peace.
EDIT:
Let's have a party at my place.
Last edited on
| zapshe wrote: |
|---|
| Let's have a party at my place. |
I’m down for that — but I don’t live near you any more. (I’m in NJ again.)
I think it’ll be the afterlife before any of us get a chance to meet up.
Last edited on
Don't mind me, just here to brag that I remembered my credentials in spite of not posting in 3 years.
Helping newbies was my favorite thing here.
Helping newbies was my favorite thing here.
There was once a time when this was my absolute favorite website. I should say I got my first serious experience at programming and game dev from this site. I don't know what made me think of this site again after all this time. But things seem down around here. I think it is just that tech has changed and upgraded so much... But this site?
It's happening to the majority of the c/C++ sites I know. None now have any where near the activity they had a couple of years ago. Even C++ blog sites don't have the postings they used to.
It is indeed very sad and tragic. RIP.
It is indeed very sad and tragic. RIP.
Dang, I remember finding this place way back in high school like 20 years ago!
> Joined: Mar 13, 2008 at 12:53pm
Almost exactly a month after Duthomhas.
> Joined: Mar 13, 2008 at 12:53pm
Almost exactly a month after Duthomhas.
lol. I signed up > Mar 19, 2011 at 6:11pm.
This has always been my go to C++ forum for questions. Lately AI has been helping a lot for simple things. Stack Overflow is great for finding answers to questions however I keep getting banned... Its just so hard to articulate my problems my topics get closed before I have the chance to revise my posts!
When I was first learning to code in C++ cplusplus was very helpful with all the tutorials and documentation.
Dream In Code was also a great site.
Thanks to everyone here with the help over the years, much appreciated!
This has always been my go to C++ forum for questions. Lately AI has been helping a lot for simple things. Stack Overflow is great for finding answers to questions however I keep getting banned... Its just so hard to articulate my problems my topics get closed before I have the chance to revise my posts!
When I was first learning to code in C++ cplusplus was very helpful with all the tutorials and documentation.
Dream In Code was also a great site.
Thanks to everyone here with the help over the years, much appreciated!
Wow, I've opened beginners forum, and there so little activity that there is no pagination. At least nobody has to worry about a question getting buried in page 3 before getting a reply. Even niche osdev forum seems more active.
Still, nice to see that some of the people who answered my stupid questions 16 years ago are still here (looking at you Duoas and firedraco).
Due to a bug or by design?
Still, nice to see that some of the people who answered my stupid questions 16 years ago are still here (looking at you Duoas and firedraco).
| Yes, people can't sign up sadly. Definitely the #1 reason this particular site has lowered traffic. |
Last edited on
Neither. The site was in the middle of an update/rewrite, but Twicker just hasn’t had that much time to dump into it for a long while now.
Pages: 12