So saying he's been in college for 3 years so he may as well finish isn't a sunk cost fallacy because that's just one factor, it's not the sole reason for continuing the degree. |
His option right now involves giving 1 year to get a degree, this is very reasonable. |
So saying he should finish since he's already been in college 3 years [...] is very reasonable |
it ACTUALLY WILL be wasted if he doesn't finish - since it brought him nothing |
It shouldn't be a factor at all. It's like saying "well, I still want to graduate, plus Venus is in ascendance with Jupiter, so I'm going to continue my studies". It's nonsense. |
As I said, I agree. That's a rational decision; it's based on the resources that need to be invested and what will be obtained. |
That's the sunk cost fallacy. You're making a decision based on your past decisions. |
Is it still reasonable? What if it takes 3 more years? 5? 10? 20? Then that 3 years have been spent is irrelevant. |
The correct way to make decisions is statelessly, as if the universe had come into existence Last Thursday. |
Will he have wasted that year when he goes to an interview and he's told that his degree is worthless (hypothetically, because in all likelihood they wouldn't even call him back), or will the year be wasted as it progresses? |
If I understood right, you're disagreeing right now with using the fact that he's been in college 3 years as a reason at all for continuing - even though it's not the only or deciding reason? |
Perhaps if it was the only reason. Here's an example of what I mean: You buy a car, turns out it's not what you exactly wanted. By the time you realize this fault in the car, it's too late to give it back to the dealer. You say, "Well, I'm already paying for it, so I may as well drive it." This would on the surface look like a sunk cost fallacy, but it isn't. You have much more to lose by NOT driving it. What are you going to do? Buy another car on top of it (even if you sell it you've basically lost a bunch of value as soon as you drove it off the lot)? Just not drive it and take a bus? It's more of a loaded statement because it seems to only give the reasoning of past decisions, but it's really more of a mental justification to accept the circumstances - where driving this car is the best financial choice available. |
The issue with this scenario is that he has a degree. It may prove useful down the line. |
However, let's think about this.. Let's say that you're going down a career path, and 3 years in, you find another career path. However, you have no personal preference either way in which path you take considering everything other than sunk cost. The balance is completely equal. Do your circuits fry? No, you say, "Well gosh! I've already spent 3 years on this one, so I may as well, stick with it!" It's the difference between finishing what those 3 years led up to, and just scrapping it. In this case, it was a deciding factor since there were no other factors to consider. |
It's important to realize that an important priority for most people is to live a life that's full, not wasted. |
Yes. Fallaciousness is "viral". If any part of an argument is fallacious then the entire argument is fallacious. It's like undefined behavior. |
Your past has already been spent so nothing you do now will change whether it was wasted. |
What's important is that people need to learn to let go of their past mistakes. Ideas such as "I've wasted x years of my life on y" are toxic to the mind and only lead to unhappiness. Identify your mistakes, learn from them, correct your behavior, and move on. What's you've done doesn't matter. All that matters is what you do now. |
If I decide to eat ice cream while I'm in no need for it (or perhaps I shouldn't have it for some reason), it doesn't make the decision to do so wrong. You can't make all life decisions based on absolute logic, otherwise you wouldn't even be on this forum debating me since it doesn't really logically help you in any way. |
You're giving up time that could be better spent. |
If you've ever watched an anime where the main character has to train for something huge, but then finds himself going astray, their master may say, "Did you forget how much work you put in!? You're going to give it all up now?!" And again, seemingly a sunk cost fallacy |
Perhaps you didn't mean to phrase it this way. If you spent 3 years in college, didn't get a degree, then came back years later to get it and you have to start all over again, those 3 years were wasted in terms of progress towards your degree. The way you phrased this sentence would almost claim that any time spent is simply time wasted. |
I assume you'd derive some pleasure from eating the ice cream |
What is wanted isn't what makes some behavior irrational. Irrational behavior arises when we let our emotions cloud our judgement and choose courses of action that don't help us achieve our goals, or perhaps even actually harm us. |
Loss aversion is very strong in humans, but irrational. Just because it works to convince people doesn't make it not a fallacy. |
My point is precisely that whether some time has been wasted exists entirely in your mind |
My present self is the result of all my past decisions, so to say that some of that was "wasted" would be to reject myself, at least in part. |
Curious question, you don't have to answer obviously, how old are you? I've been curious. |
Well, I meant as in the ice cream goes against a greater goal, let's say attaining a six pack. Eating the ice cream would be illogical, assuming you'd greater enjoy having a six pack than downing some ice cream. And let's assume you must forgo ice cream to get a six pack in this scenario. In this case, eating the ice cream is illogical, since you picked a short-lived happiness with a greater longer-lived one. |
Lol! I bet if you were in that situation you'd say, "It hurts! Why must I be swayed by unreason?!" |
This is only half right. If you spent 3 year to get a degree and then don't get it. Those 3 years are wasted, because the goal you wanted to reach with the time spent wasn't reached. You can find some greater take away if you want, say you learned, had fun, lost your v-card, etc.. But in the end, it was still really wasted in that the goal the time was spent on went unachieved. |
Well, it's not exactly rejecting yourself. We're not such perfect beings that our emotions won't conflict. For example, having a child too early and ruining opportunities may be a regret. However, asked if they regret having *insert child's name* and they may so no. They regret the situation, they don't regret the outcome. Contradictory, but I'd bet many people would have this exact contradiction in mind. |
My birthday is on my profile |
Well, we face that every day, don't we? We suffer because we let ourselves be led astray from our goals by our emotions. Our laziness and gluttony keeps us from having our chiseled abs and our PhDs. |
Speaking for myself, I do not see the time I spent in university not getting a degree as wasted. I don't know how you're going to convince me of the opposite. |
I'd give anything to be able to turn the clock back to 2016 |
Hell, I'll go even further: you're not an adult if you've never done something you'll always regret. |
But I still don't think any time was a waste. It's not a matter of "being a perfect being", it's about always learning from your experiences and constantly being your best self. |
If that's your case then I'll grant you that you really are wasting time |
Well, this is because you got a rewarding job, which was the point of trying to get the degree. |
One second we're talking about logical fallacies the next we're crying and talking about being an adult :( |
it doesn't mean that one can't reflect on life and think, "wow, I wasted a lot of time on nothing." Where time was spent, probably repetitively, and it felt like nothing was truly gained from it |
The point is that someone going to college and gaining nothing from it would probably find that the time was wasted, even if you wouldn't specifically think so. |
I did learn some very useful things, like linear algebra and number theory, and some less useful things, like chemistry and correctness proofs. |
Well, we're also talking about life decisions. Plus, you're the one who brought up regrets. |
My point is not that you can't do it, but that you don't have to do it. |
I think if someone went to college and literally all they got out of it was a piece of paper saying they went to college, then even if they finished they really did waste their time. |
Christ, all that effort just for that? What a world. What a way to spend your finite time. |
helios wrote: |
---|
I think if someone went to college and... |
Sometimes I wanna marry you, sometimes I wanna choke you. |
I think you are far too emotionally connected to somebody else you have met on an internet forum. It's just a cplusplus forum. |
it was clearly a joke |
Someone else who may not have even cared much for the field may find they've wasted their time, and probably forgotten what they were "learning" after the class is over. |
You don't have to look at time as wasted, but sometimes it is by definition |
You don't have to look at time as wasted, but sometimes it is by definition and you can't help but feel that it truly was. |
For example, I was at an interview with a company not too long ago. They quizzed me on C++ stuff and I'm sure I did well. They asked what year of college I was in and I said it was my second, and immediately the tone shifted. Asked me if I was looking for an internship. |
with regards to education, what is it that causes people to get jobs they loathe (provided they intend to acquire a job they would find rewarding)? |
Either way, it was clearly a joke. |
If you go to college to learn about something you don't care much about, that sounds like an express road to career frustration. |
OK, when is something wasted? |
You don't have to you can't help it? Get your argument straight. |
Just get your foot in the door, man. Even if you have to work for free. Right now you're paying to work. Just saying. It's up to you. |
Aw... But I'd already been checking out belts and wedding dresses... |
Just because you don't have to feel like your time was wasted doesn't mean you won't feel that. |
Hang pictures all over your house of all your loved ones who've died (if possible, taken the moment they died) |
It's not about being happy with failure, it's about finding the silver lining. |