So I finished the entire series.
Over time they pretty much improved on everyone's character... except for Korra, strangely enough. She stayed pretty consistent throughout the entire series. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, I guess I just expected more growth from the main character.
By the end I really liked Mako and even Bo Lin. And other characters too.. like the Beifong family really got me sucked in... and even Tenzin's kids... except for Meelo -- God I hate that twerp. Every line that came out of his mouth I just wanted to punch him.
I loved Verrick. He seems like an eccentric sleaze at first, and I thought I knew where his character was going to go -- and I was right in that it went where I thought it would... but it didn't finish there. His character sort of redefined itself.
Overall summary of the seasons:
Season 1 has a very, very slow start, but ultimately turns it around with a really interesting and suspenseful climax. Aman was pretty bland at first, but once they got into his backstory he became slightly more interesting. Overall the season was pretty good as it did a good job of introducing the world and the characters, while presenting an interesting conflict. But there was a LOT of stuff they could have cut out -- or at least reworked to be more interesting.
Season 2 is definately my least favorite. Pretty much the whole season was Korra walking into an obvious trap and making one horrible mistake after another. The villain wasn't even that interesting either. The action was good and the storyline was decent I guess... but what really kept me watching was Verrick and the psycho water-bending cousin whose name I can't remember.
The whole backstory about Avatar Juan was kind of bland. It's not that it didn't fit with the show... it's just that... I dunno. I just didn't really like it. It was kind of boring and Juan wasn't very likable. And the climax was pretty disappointing -- apart from being entirely predictable it ended up being "transform into giant -- giant monster fight" which is pretty lame and uninteresting... like a bad Power Rangers episode. On top of that, Jinora chimed in last minute with a completely unexplained sort of Deus Ex Machina to save the day. Seriously, they never explained what she did or why it worked -- it was completely lazy.
After Season 2 I was almost ready to call it quits, but I figured the show was entertaining enough to keep going... so I persevered. And boy am I glad I did. Season 3 took me on a ride. The villains -- Zaheer and his entourage -- were not only menacing and awesome, but strangely identifiable and at times were even somewhat sympathetic.
Season 3 got DARK, too. Like they really took off the kid gloves, which I was surpised to see, this being Nickelodeon and all. But they flat out start killing characters rather than just capturing them. And brutally, too. P'Li's death (Zaheer's girlfriend -- the one that shoots explosions from her face) made me double-take. I had to rewind it a few times to make sure... "did they really just do that? On
Nickelodeon?". Granted they don't actually show her dying, but they show HOW she dies, and they don't really leave much to the imagination.
Seriously:
https://youtu.be/vFWuQ30Hi8k .. remember, she shoots explosions from her face.
And Tenzin basically gets beat down and borderline tortured. I mean it was fucking DARK. Even the ending was dark. Korra is left off in really bad shape and the epilogue wasn't even cheerful as much as it was bittersweet.
So yeah... season 3 had pretty much everything. Great character backstory and development with the Beifong family, a terrific villain and a truely interesting and gripping climax. I was hooked beginning to end, and it restored all the faith I had in the show, and I expected great things from season 4.
... and it did not disappoint. I can't decide if I like it more than season 3 or not, but
damn was season 4 good. While I didn't like the villain as much as Zaheer, she certainly was good. Clear motivation, she made sense, and while she wasn't nearly as sympathetic or identifiable as Zaheer was, you at least could follow her.
And I
really liked what they did with the support characters. Bo Lin really stepped up and came into his own rather than just being the tag-along dufus he normally was (although that didn't really happen until like halfway through the season). Verrick's character came full circle and really blew me away. They even brought his assistant Zhu Li more into the spotlight. Even Prince Wu, who I thought was going to be throw-away comic relief ended up being pretty cool.
And what they did to Korra -- I was kind of stunned. They carried over the idea of her being damaged from the end of Season 3 and she spends a good portion of season 4 trying to come to grips with it and overcome it -- all the while having to fight with the guilt of what her 3-year absence has caused. And it's all done sort of metaphysically -- it's really interesting to watch.
Pretty much every single episode of season 4 had me glued to my seat -- except for the flashback episode (blech). The only thing I didn't like about it was fucking Meelo. What an annoying twit. Fortunately he only had a few lines -- but good lord did they stand out. Ugh. Seriously... every single word that came out of his fucking mouth was insufferable -- I've never hated any on-screen character as much as I've hated that kid. I was actually shouting "get that fucking kid off the screen!" while watching.
And the surprise ending -- which
really had me surprised. Not because I didn't see it coming -- I mean I saw clues for it throughout season 4 (maybe they were even doing it earlier) -- but man I just did
not expect
Nickelodeon to actually go through with it... with a
kid's show. When I actually saw it my jaw dropped. Again they don't show anything explicit, but it's very clear and is impossible to misinterpet. I won't spoil the ending for those who haven't seen it, but it's really clever.
So yeah. This show won me over big time. I don't know if I like it more than Avatar or not -- but it's a damn good show. If you can stick it through the slow first two seasons, it is definitely worth a watch.